Courier Times: Residents ask solicitor to abstain
By SETH GOLDSTEIN
Courier Times
COUNCIL ROCK - More than 10 angry Upper Makefield residents appeared at the Council Rock school board meeting Thursday night to ask the district's solicitor to recuse himself from any dealings with Toll Brothers and to answer allegations of back-room dealings with the builder.
Jane Johnson, the only resident who spoke for the group during public comment at the beginning of the meeting, expressed her opposition to Toll Brothers' attempt to rezone the district-owned Melsky property and another tract of land, both on Dolington Road, for high-density housing.
Johnson told the board that hundreds of Upper Makefield residents have signed a petition against the sale of the district's property to the developers.
She asked board solicitor Derek Reid to recuse himself from any district business dealing with Toll and the properties, because Reid's business partner represents Toll Brothers in the land-purchasing litigation.
“The sale of the Melsky tract by the Council Rock School District to Toll Brothers is not in the best interest of the taxpayers of this community,” Johnson said. “The very fact that your firm represents Toll Brothers in this very litigation puts you in a direct position of conflict representing the interests of the taxpayers you were hired to serve.”
Johnson alleged that Reid had a more direct role in the development of the properties.
“Mr. Robert West, an Upper Makefield supervisor, said at last night's township meeting that you, Mr. Reid, were approached by a representative of Toll Brothers in August of last year to purchase the Melsky tract with money that Toll Brothers would receive from the Department of Veterans Affairs for 200 acres of the Dolington Land tract,” she said.
Reid refused to comment on the accusations.
The school board meeting was the second time in two days where issues revolving around the development along Dolington Road were addressed.
At their Wednesday night meeting, the Upper Makefield Board of Supervisors, in a move to force Toll Brothers to the table, withdrew a land rezoning ordinance that would have allowed the veterans cemetery and the proposed 210 Toll homes to progress.
Supervisor Dan Rattigan said the plan for 210 homes is more than what is allowed and that Toll should follow the current zoning instead of requesting rezoning.
Seth Goldstein, a freelance writer, can be reached at news@phillyBurbs.com.
Courier Times
COUNCIL ROCK - More than 10 angry Upper Makefield residents appeared at the Council Rock school board meeting Thursday night to ask the district's solicitor to recuse himself from any dealings with Toll Brothers and to answer allegations of back-room dealings with the builder.
Jane Johnson, the only resident who spoke for the group during public comment at the beginning of the meeting, expressed her opposition to Toll Brothers' attempt to rezone the district-owned Melsky property and another tract of land, both on Dolington Road, for high-density housing.
Johnson told the board that hundreds of Upper Makefield residents have signed a petition against the sale of the district's property to the developers.
She asked board solicitor Derek Reid to recuse himself from any district business dealing with Toll and the properties, because Reid's business partner represents Toll Brothers in the land-purchasing litigation.
“The sale of the Melsky tract by the Council Rock School District to Toll Brothers is not in the best interest of the taxpayers of this community,” Johnson said. “The very fact that your firm represents Toll Brothers in this very litigation puts you in a direct position of conflict representing the interests of the taxpayers you were hired to serve.”
Johnson alleged that Reid had a more direct role in the development of the properties.
“Mr. Robert West, an Upper Makefield supervisor, said at last night's township meeting that you, Mr. Reid, were approached by a representative of Toll Brothers in August of last year to purchase the Melsky tract with money that Toll Brothers would receive from the Department of Veterans Affairs for 200 acres of the Dolington Land tract,” she said.
Reid refused to comment on the accusations.
The school board meeting was the second time in two days where issues revolving around the development along Dolington Road were addressed.
At their Wednesday night meeting, the Upper Makefield Board of Supervisors, in a move to force Toll Brothers to the table, withdrew a land rezoning ordinance that would have allowed the veterans cemetery and the proposed 210 Toll homes to progress.
Supervisor Dan Rattigan said the plan for 210 homes is more than what is allowed and that Toll should follow the current zoning instead of requesting rezoning.
Seth Goldstein, a freelance writer, can be reached at news@phillyBurbs.com.

